How to Catch Pirate Captain's Goldfish in Fisch
SecretC$ 6,520/kg•Forsaken Shores
Updated Oct 31, 2026
Where
Forsaken Shores
When
Day
Weather
Any
Avg Sale
C$ 14,671
Extreme
The Pirate Captain's Goldfish is a Secret goldfish of the freshwater pond at Forsaken Shores.
Advertisement
Spawn Locations
How to Catch It
Fish at Forsaken Shores, best in Summer, during the day; use the No-Life Rod with Truffle Worm bait.
- Bait it prefers
- Truffle Worm
- Rod
- No-Life RodThe Fisch Wiki's pick for this fish
- Reeling
- No progress penalty
- XP per catch
- 24,800 before bonuses
From the Pirate Captain's Goldfish's page on the Fisch Wiki, checked November 10, 2026.
NPC Sell Value
Price and weight checked 2026-10-04. Wiki source. Player trade prices may differ.
NPC price per kg
C$ 6,520/kg
Natural weight range
1.5-6.3 kg
Average catch
C$ 14,671
With Tryhard mutation (10x): C$ 146,708
Pro Catching Strategy
Fish the Forsaken Shores freshwater pond by day with Truffle Worm; Summer raises your chances. It is a rare bite.
Advertisement
Fishing here?
See all fish at Forsaken Shores and which ones are most profitable for your rod.
Profit OptimizerAlso at this location
Spawn Conditions
- Time
- Day
- Weather
- Any
- Season
- Summer
Continue reading

Next step
Fisch Trade & Value Calculator
Pick a fish, enter its weight and mutation, and see what it sells for.
Go thereMore fish guides
Advertisement